cool hit counter

Who ate all the pies

Dip in to scour the latest Deadline Day titbits...

Who Ate All The Pies Logo

Ratings: Barcelona 4-1 Arsenal – Messi Is The Perfect 10

By Ollie Irish

Pies has the scores on the doors from a memorable night in the Nou Camp:

BARCELONA

Victor Valdes – Little to do. VV spent most of the game watching Lionel Messi skip towards Manuel Almunia. Unlucky to parry Nicklas Bendtner’s shot back into the Dane’s path. 7

Dani Alves - Incredible work rate. He’s a genuine winger and full-back combined. You wouldn’t f**k with him either – he can be a nasty sod when the mood takes him and he’ll dive when he needs to. 7

Gabriel Milito - A more-than-capable deputy. He wasn’t really tested, apart from one excellent sliding tackle on Bendtner. 8

Rafael Marquez - Concerns about his lack of pace unfounded. A solid display. Kicked Rosicky out of the game. 7

Eric Abidal - Kept on the back foot in the first half by Theo Walcott and as a result he made a couple of mistakes. Replaced by Maxwell early in the second half. 6

Sergio Busquets - I’m a massive fan of Biscuits. He was my man of the match in the first leg and he showed again what a terrific prospect he is, with a dominant display in midfield. He’s not afraid to get stuck in either, though he should have been booked for a professional foul on Walcott. 8

Seydou Keita - Much better than in the first leg. This time he was all over the place, but in a good way. 7

Xavi - The best midfielder in the world? Yeah, I think so. He misplaced just 15 of his 244 passes last night. Incredible. You can’t help but marvel at his control, intelligence and range of short passing. He makes the game look so simple. 9

Bojan Krkic - A quiet night. Didn’t do much wrong but was completely overshadowed by Messi. 6

Lionel Messi - I think we’ve all run out of words to describe Leo’s jaw-unhinging brilliance. I’ll go with a simple “wow”. Wow x4. 10 MAN OF THE MATCH (Who else!?)

Pedro – Some good runs and nice touches but his finishing was below-par. Works very hard for his team though, and you can see why Barca’s fans love him. 7

* * * * *

ARSENAL

Manuel Almunia – Looked a bit nervous early on, when his distribution was patchy. Made to look foolish by Messi (no disgrace) for Barca’s fourth goal, but couldn’t have done much better for the first three. I’ll say it again though: Arsenal needs a better No.1. 6

Bacary Sagna - A typical Sagna performance. Didn’t do much wrong, but didn’t catch the eye either. 6

Mikael Silvestre - At fault for Messi’s first two goals. On the back foot all night. Will have nightmares about Messi for a long time. Would Sol Campbell have done any better though? 4

Thomas Vermaelen - Many of you threw your toys out when I failed to include Vermaelen in a Barcelona-Arsenal composite XI (I had Pique and Gallas as the centre-back pairing) but I think his two displays against Barcelona have proved that he is still a raw, inexperienced defender with a lot to learn. He was better in the second leg though, and put in a hell of a lot of work – but when Silvestre is your partner at the back and Messi is running at you, you’re in a world of pain. 6

Gael Clichy - A mix of good and bad, with more of the former. Ran his socks off and put in some decent balls (especially one for Bendtner in the second half) but also played Messi onside for his third goal. Still, he looks much more like the dashing Clichy of old than he did earlier this season. 7

Denilson - Very harshly booked for a legit tackle on Messi. The yellow card seemed to subdue the young Brazilian and he was never a factor thereafter. 5

Abou Diaby - So much better than in the first leg. He was everywhere for Arsenal, putting his long legs in where it counted. Set up Arsenal’s goal but should have released Walcott a second time when he had the chance at 1-0. Instead he passed to Bendtner and the attack came to nothing. 7

Samir Nasri - Worked very hard closing down Barca’s back four, then took a knock on his ankle that slowed him down. Never looked like getting the upper hand against Xavi, Keita and Busquets. 6

Tomas Rosicky - Clattered by Marquez early doors, didn’t fancy it after that. Too fragile, past it, must be sold in the summer – if anyone will buy? 4

Theo Walcott - Almost fucked up Arsenal’s goal with a nervous pass to Bendtner – a better player would have gone for goal himself. Still doubts his own ability – only his pace is without question. What would Theo give to swap 10% of his pace for just 1/100th of Messi’s talent? 5

Nicklas Bendtner - Certainly not overawed but in terms of ability he’s no Robin van Persie (well, in his head maybe). Took his goal very well but didn’t do a heck of a lot after that. 7

There you go. First 10/10 I’ve ever awarded, I think. Messi almost went up to 11. Agree with the ratings?

Digg This
Reddit This
Stumble Now!
Buzz This
Vote on DZone
Share on Facebook
Bookmark this on Delicious
Kick It on DotNetKicks.com
Shout it
Share on LinkedIn
Bookmark this on Technorati
Post on Twitter
Google Buzz (aka. Google Reader)

By Ollie Irish on April 7th, 2010 in Arsenal, Barcelona, Champions League, Featured. You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS 2.0 feed. You can leave a response, or trackback from your own site.
comments

7 Responses to “Ratings: Barcelona 4-1 Arsenal – Messi Is The Perfect 10”

  1. [...] best pics from Camp Nou (ratings here): ◄ Back Next ► Picture 1 of 24 Barcelona's starting [...]

  2. Michael says:

    Agree with your assesment of the match except on one point regarding Bendtner. You say he did not do a lot more than score his early goal. Not only did he have a header on the post in the 70th minute at 3-1 to Barcelona which could have added a lot of pressure in the last 20-25 minutes, he also had a one on one with the keeper at 1-1 which the ref called offside. Slow motion show 1-2 meter mistake which was at a critical time also. Bendtner by far Arsenals best and in my view he is starting to show the form which could make him a great player for the Gunners in future years.

  3. David says:

    Bendtner should have scored a hattrick, a 7 is generous.

  4. Jelly Bean says:

    I’m glad it’s not just me that thought that player was called Biscuits!

  5. kritter says:

    Rosicky didn’t have a good match at all, but I don’t think he’s past it yet. He’s a great squad player, played in about 50% of the Prem matches this year and is capable of briliance at times. It’s certainly nice to have experience like him on the bench for the inevitable injuries Arsenal incur.

  6. rjahuey says:

    Rafael Marquez – Concerns about his lack of pace unfounded. A solid display. Kicked Rosicky out of the game. ….. 7? What do you, Barza People, need to recognize his work, dedication and quality?

  7. Moscos Omollo says:

    Let’s face it – this happens to Arsenal every season – They have a thin squad and invariably there are injuries in this physical sport – so every year, the first team players take the team to the peak and then towards the end of the season the 3rd team players bring them back to mother earth (as most of the 1st team players are sitting on the pot – injured)!

    When will Arsene Wenger learn …When? I hope that this summer with our new CEO in place we buy good players to sustain us till May 2011.

Leave a Reply