What’s wrong with Rafa Benitez saying Everton are a small club?


5th, February 2007


Rafa_1Rafa Benitez referred to Everton as a small club at the weekend and it ruffled some feathers.  The Spaniard said after Saturday’s 0-0 Merseyside derby: "When you play against the smaller teams at Anfield you know the game will be narrow."
Everton chief executive Keith Wyness responded on the club website and said: "Benitez is in a minority of one in believing Everton is a small club. Somehow we just expect more of a Liverpool manager." Boo Hoo. If Everton are a big club, then I’m not sure what defines a football club as ‘big’.

There is no doubt in my mind that Everton have a rich history in football. They’ve won all sorts of trophies, have a loyal fan base and have been in the top flight longer than anyone else. Fair enough… they’re an important side with lots of heritage. Does that make them a big side? Well, not in my book. A big side commands the best players from around Europe, a side that consistantly reaches the Champions League, a side that genuinely challenges for trophies year after year. Liverpool, ManYoo and Arsenal are the only three English teams who can stake a claim for this. You may be wondering about Chelsea… but they’ve only been challenging since a certain Russian billionaire got involved.

If a club can claim to be big on heritage alone, then Wolves, Burnley, Notts Forest and Bolton Wanderers are big clubs. Somehow, I doubt you’ll find many who would agree on that. If you look at a side like West Ham, many fans hark on about the spirit of Bobby Moore, and how it was their side that won the World Cup for England. Of course, that’s not true, but it shows a side with lots of heritage to look back on. However, like West Ham, Everton haven’t had much to crow about in recent years… in fact, apart from the FA Cup, Everton have done nothing.

Why should Rafa Benitez give Everton any credit? Not since the days of Neville Southall have Everton caused anyone any major problems. As far as he’s concerned, they’re local rivals, and not much else. Fair enough. Also, since when did Liverpool and Everton show each other the love? I love a bit of tension between rivals… and it’s refreshing to see the Liverpool manager sticking the boot in on his neighbours. As a Bolton fan, I’d be punching the air if Sam Allardyce referred to Wigan as "those shitty pie eaters from down the road". I’d also be furious if Paul Jewell slagged us off… but that’s what football is all about. It’s about time we had a bit of banter between clubs instead of all this PR guff. [Mof Gimmers]

Posted in Everton, Liverpool

Share this article: Email


  1. OmegaSupremeho says:

    The comment is better left ignored, a petty jibe from a disgruntled manager. Having just been frustrated and coming out saying that just makes him look small. It’s childish, the equivalent of Moyssie coming out and saying “well yo mamman don’t think I’m too small”
    Besides playing for a draw at a hard away match would be considered smart tactics by many foriegn fans. Do we have to always be the plucky English losers ?
    Everton are a proper club, with the history and support to back it up. I’d put half a dozen or so clubs in that bracket.

  2. sam says:

    “Proper” still doesn’t mean “big” though does it?

  3. david says:

    Proper? What the hell does that mean?
    I’m a Liverpool fan, and like most Reds fans, I have respect for Everton, though I know that not many from their side return the respect.

  4. StuMo says:

    Just thought it was a great bit of derby rivalry. More please!
    Shankly said a lot worse (or better, if you will) – what’s the big deal?
    Everton should lighten up. Their over-reaction to a throwaway comment in the middle of an interview only serves to shows how close to the bone it was.

  5. joe says:

    People need to stop getting so insulted by every little soundbite. This isn’t a cattilion.

  6. Stuey says:

    It’s just a lame, cheap jibe to distract from the fact that his team dropped 5 points against their local rivals.

  7. dave says:

    everton are a massive club u’v only got to look at the facts to know that just beacause they’v had a bad peroid every top club in this contry has had a bad period liverpool in the early days manutd in the 70’s chelsea were up and down in the 80’s everton have a big fanbase u know so how can everton be a small club on 10years of crap u cant juge a clubs size on that because then thats like saying that man utd werent a big club when they went down in the 70’s everton are a gr8 club who are working up to be a top 5 club again and they will be IF YA KNOW YA HISTORY

  8. notmyrealname says:

    Everton are a small club. The club’s fanbase and spirit seems to be dying, with Liverpool taking over more and more of the fanbase. History means nothing when you look at the present.

  9. blue4 life says:

    look it up look it the history wat make the size of a football club its history man utd big club coz of there history that was before ferguson are people tell me that before that time man utd were better than everton u know it at liverpool 10 years of doing nothing under souness and evans nothing till 2001 they dnt get classed as a small club but everton do we are a big club anybody who knows anything about football will know that thank you