Comments on: Pro Evo 2010 v FIFA 10: which one will you buy?

By: Jose Martinez

Jose Martinez — Sun, 16 Oct 2011 14:17:53 +0000

I’ve played both Fifa 12 and Pro 12 in the past three days. I bought Pro. Fifa is so easy its pathetic, its the kids version of football games. Everything looks like TV fair play but the game play is so 1980′s in the arcade still pro’s gameplay shoots it down every year.

By: Dennis

Dennis — Tue, 16 Nov 2010 10:32:50 +0000

The truth? The truth is this … if you are a true gamer and that’s all it’s about for you, the most likely you’ll probably be a PES fan;
but if, like me, you are a purist football fan playing the game for enjoyment at stadiums like the real thing and you’re in luv with the tactical aspect of the game both in real life and therefore on the game, then I honestly cannot fathom how you can favour PES over FIFA.
They don’t call it “the beautiful game” for nothing and one of PES’ biggest problems in my humble opinion is the game speed and physical field size; it is simply too fast and the guys run around on the field like they’ve all swallowed batteries and they can turn on a dime – like they are wearing dancing shoes! Also you can run from out of screen and tackle a guy before he even has time to react! Come on guys, on the real stage this is far from realistic. And just some clarity on something; when you play the game albeit PES or FIFA, you are the player and manager and tactics are what wins games – on the real stage …

By: Liam

Liam — Wed, 13 Oct 2010 13:53:36 +0000

fifa is too good for pes.

By: Tom

Tom — Fri, 20 Aug 2010 16:36:01 +0000

I always use to buy pes until that went down hill by about pes 6. Bin buyin fifa up till 2010 an all i can say is that its gradually got worse and worse. fifa 08 was the best, the game was slower and a lot more realistic. I must say though fifa 10 is the bigges pile of shite ive played. Its no longer a case of knowing the game of footbal tacticly, its now a matter of how many different seemlesly easy tricks you can perform, how many 1 – 2′s you can do, its how many times you can make a tacke only to find the the attacker has magicly bounced his way through, Its watching the ball bounce back and forth like a game of tennis. Ive played this game on line a fair bit and i can tell you that you will convincingly beat some1 play them again and loose. There is far to much luck involved and know way of knowing if your any good at it.

By: John Doe

John Doe — Wed, 14 Jul 2010 07:52:36 +0000

Fifa 2010 is defintely for kids. The online experience is simply horrible. If you win 5 consecutives matches or more, a defeat will soon arrive simply because your players will not respond to your controller and all due to a series of ingenuous plays controlled by the CPU.

Once in a while you get defeted by 5 x 0 scores (weird scores), even if you are on level 20 or above playing a five year old, just because the CPU will adjust the handicap and force all your players to: leave tons of gaps, give away passes, miss open goals, let the ball in between the defender’s legs during crucial plays, and tons of other weird things. Also on top of all you can miss at least 20 shots on target, while your opponent will simply press the shooting button and the CPU will handle the rest.

I think that EA does it on purpose, it’s a marketing strategy, “no one wins it all, by all means”, that way if a newcomer purchases the game just by curiosity, the chances to win a few matches with the CPU’s help are increased, therfore the satisfaction is guaranteed. The player will always come back for the newer version, otherwise he/she would loose interest in the game.

Great graphics, but the rest is garbage.

PES 2010.

By: Tommy

Tommy — Tue, 29 Jun 2010 12:37:00 +0000

I don’t understand how I went from winning 99% of games in Fifa09 to winning 60% in Fifa10. I can only conclude the tactics are all messed up. I didn’t buy PES10 simply because last years was a disaster. I am happy with the gameplay in FIFA10 but I think it has become too tactical, where people make their own tactics and it is impossible to play against.

By: Shawn

Shawn — Thu, 17 Jun 2010 15:46:44 +0000

Pro evo is played at a 100mph, there is no power gauge for passing, through balls are awful, when you press pass it happens about 2 seconds late, even stuff like the keepers doesnt have a power gauge when you throw the ball out.
Fifa is technically streets ahead and more realistic and ultimately more fun. You can keep possesion in fifa, play balls over the top, you acctually have to have the wright player on fifa to shoot outside the box rather than pro evo which is more suited to be played in a arcade for 50p a play.

Fifa online is superb also!. i find it amazing how somebody can prefer pro evo over fifa, and yes, i have played both. Its the people who havent played both who give the worst opinions

By: Anonymous

Anonymous — Tue, 15 Jun 2010 15:43:14 +0000

Guys iv’e played pro along time but pro 10 sucks big time. The refs almost never give penalty kicks and never play out THE advantage. U can always kickdown players that are not close to THE ball without getting booked. And THE commentary always saus the same boring crap. I hope pro 11 wil be normal Again.

By: Kevin

Kevin — Thu, 10 Jun 2010 16:06:16 +0000

I bought both with an open mind. After 1 play on each there was onlt going to be one winner. Pro Evo’s better graphics and far superior gameplay wins hands down. Fifa is like a chils game and anybody could play it so therefore no skill involved.

By: isaac

isaac — Sun, 30 May 2010 13:16:14 +0000

add to my pay