DISCLAIMER: All Who Ate All the Pies’ lists lack objectivity, so if you disagree with any of our choices then please vent your spleen by adding a comment. (Of course, I’ll still be right…)
10 Most Overrated Players in the Premiership continued…
10 Xabi Alonso
I’ve never understood the hype, personally.
9 Claude Makelele
Sits in front of the best defence in the country, makes a few tackles and then passes the ball sideways. Easy peasy.
8 Stewart Downing
He makes Gareth Barry look good. ‘Nuff said.
7 Jermain Defoe
I’ve heard more than one misguided commentator call him the best natural goalscorer in England (David Platt, for one). Utter rubbish.
6 Pepe Reina
The horse has bolted on this one, but I never rated the big Spaniard (honestly!). No improvement on Dudek really.
5 Jermaine Jenas
Like a pencil without lead… pointless.
4 Peter Crouch
Set to attack Bobby Charlton’s England goalscoring record! Hmm, if England continues to play Andorra, Jamaica and Macedonia every other week, maybe. Otherwise, be serious.
3 Phil Neville
Does the dirty work, unsung hero blah blah blah – admit it, he’s a bit pants.
2 Wes Brown
This may upset Man U fans, but I’ve never understood why Wesley is so highly rated. If someone can please explain it to me, I’d be more than happy to listen…