1901 FA Cup Final: Non-League Winners, Football’s First On-Screen Refereeing Controversy & 6,000 Pork Pies

Martin Cloake

20th, April 2016


On 20th April 1901, the biggest crowd ever to attend a football match anywhere in the world descended on Crystal Palace Park in South East London.

The occasion was the FA Cup Final and what enticed the official attendance of 114,815 – many more gained entrance unofficially – was not just the culmination of a competition already established as the world’s foremost football tournament, but what the two competing sides represented.

The teams in question were Tottenham Hotspur and Sheffield United. Spurs were a non-league side, playing in the amateur Southern League. The Blades were an established football power from the professional Football League.

Underdogs versus giants. Amateur versus professional. The industrial north versus the suburban south. This was a final that really caught the public’s imagination.

It was a momentous day. Spurs would eventually win after a replay, becoming the first and remaining only non-league team to win the FA Cup.

However, the first tie in front of the immense throng at the Crystal Palace ground is also notable for featuring the first moving picture refereeing controversy.

Film was a new technology at the time, and emerging newsreel companies scoured the land in search of events to film and broadcast at local cinemas. The cameras were at the Crystal Palace that day, and were fortunate enough to witness referee Arthur Kingscott dropping a clanger.

Tottenham’s goalkeeper George Clawley fumbled a cross just wide of the goalpost, but Kingscott ruled it had gone in. There were no nets in those days so the decision stood, and the game was drawn 2-2.

The sense of injustice at what was popularly dubbed “the goal that never was” helped – if you’ll excuse the pun – spur support for the London side, who won the replay at Burnden Park in Bolton by three goals to one.

That game was watched by just 30,000 after rail companies refused to lay on cheap trains. Some things never change.

To get some idea of the size of the crowd that packed into the aforementioned first tie, here’s a list of the food laid on by the caterers that day…

12,000 slices of bread and butter
4,500 loaves
21,000 rolls
55,120 portions of cake
1,000 sponge cakes
1,000 pieces of shortbread
20,000 French pastries
10,000 Bath buns
10,000 plain buns
24,000 scones
6,000 pork pies
2,000 smoked sausages
1,728 gallons of milk
200 rumps of beef
250 chines of mutton
150 best ends of mutton
60 foreribs of beef
40 whole lambs
300 quarters of whitebait
500lb soles
22,400lb potatoes
2,000 cabbages and cauliflowers
400 fowls
200 ducks
120,000 bottles of mineral water

Sure beats the overpriced (and barely edible) pie-and-a-pint combo on sale at modern finals.

You can follow Martin Cloake on Twitter at @MartinCloake and find more about his books and writing at www.martincloake.com

Posted in FA Cup, Featured, Retro, Tottenham Hotspur

Share this article: Email

Leave a Reply