‘Liverpool Need Someone Creative, Like Graeme Souness’ – Danny Murphy Has Some Incredibly Silly Reservations About Naby Keita

Chris Wright

9th, January 2018


Embed from Getty Images

Naby Keita is currently whiling away the days at RB Liepzig ahead of his imminent move to Liverpool, which is ear-marked to go through on July 1st, 2018.

Since the €75million deal was struck between the two clubs in August, Keita has plateaued ever so slightly so, in his dual role as both an ex-Reds midfielder and Sky Sports’ in-house Bundesliga shaman, Danny Murphy was afforded the opportunity to air his reservations.

Appearing on The Debate, Murphy offered the following observations on Keita and the quandary his impending move to Anfield has created (via Football365):

I’m not sure (on Keita), from what I’ve seen.

Subconsciously you can look like you’ve downed tools when you’re protecting yourself a little bit, I wouldn’t judge him on that. I don’t know him well enough to say that.

What I would say is he’s obviously very athletic, got a lot of qualities – a bit like Jordan Henderson has. Professional, good athlete, does his job really, really well.

But he isn’t creative enough if you want to challenge for the title and the Champions League. Someone like Gerrard, Souness, Alonso, Mascherano – these type of players.

Ignoring the thinly-veiled stereotyping, that’s just twaddle. Complete and utter.

Not only has Murphy quite obviously never seen Keita play, it sounds like he’s never seen Graeme Souness or Javier Mascherano play either. “Creative”? We honestly can’t think of an adjective less suitable to describe either.

Souness spent a career sating his perverse fetish for wounding lesser mortals and Mascherano suffers sudden-onset altitude sickness every time he crosses the half-way line.

Pies have got nothing against Murphy (other than the fact his joyless commentary delivery is somewhere akin to a man telling his wife about the neighbour’s dog fouling the grass verge outside for the umpteenth time) but why is he being tasked with scrutinising the strengths and weaknesses of a player he’s entirely unfamiliar with under the guise of legitimate in-depth analysis?

The problem, as ever, lies with Sky Sports and their staunch commitment to noise over nous.

Posted in Bundesliga, Liverpool, Transfers & Rumours

Share this article: Email


  1. Manny Durphy says:

    Noise over nous captures it perfectly.

    From what I’ve seen of Naby Keita, I think he’ll click nicely with Wijnaldum and Lallana.. Not sure they can compete with KDB, David Silva, and Fernandinho but they’re building a solid team in Liverpool.. Not a City fan, just observing.

    Btw as a longtime Pies reader and knowing your love for Forest, it was great to see their desire and ability get them past Arsenal! Reading your letter afterwards great too.. as a Newcastle United fan, I could relate to the boardroom/backrroom shambles that sometimes tarnishes a once proud people’s club.. Was there no chance for Gary Brazil to get the manager gig permanently?
    I think there’s a lot to be said for progressing managers and players together from a young age, letting them grow together in time creates something (team ethic?) that can be greater than the sum of its parts..

    • Chris Wright says:

      Cheers Manny.

      On Forest, Gary Brazil is a great coach and is as close to ‘job for life’ status at Forest as it’s possible to get.

      One excellent result shouldn’t mask the need for an established long-term solution.

      Personally, I’m chuffed with Karanka. He should tighten up the defence and begin stamping out all the needless possession errors that have been undermining us all season.

Leave a Reply